RE: Errors in author's versions

["David Goodman" <David.Goodman@liu.edu>]

Dear Anthony,

I have no intention of influencing the US government-- it is 
perhaps the furthest thing from my thoughts. Do not confuse me 
with those who do.

You have told me about editors' salaries, and indicated evidence, 
and so have others, and I then agree my previous undersanding was 
incorrect.

But the argument against author copies presented here by some 
biomedical societies was about serious scientific errors, and I 
will believe such an error when the citations to the print and OA 
versions are given, or similar physical data produced.

It is not only you and I both who have failed to find them. There 
are several hundred people reading this list who are in a 
position to know of any. There were some postings that there 
might conceivably be such errors in the future. I take that as an 
admission that they too have not found any now.

Anthony, I would not accept anyone's word in place of possible 
data, whether or not it confirms my prejudices. I should never 
have deserved the doctorate you keep mentioning if I worked 
otherwise.

David Goodman
dgoodman@princeton.edu

I see no reason to post again on this topic, except to discuss 
something that exists.